Tuesday, October 16, 2007

George Will loses it!

In his column in today's Washington Post, "The Unforgotten Man", George Will states:

"Politics often operates on the Humpty Dumpty Rule (in 'Through the Looking Glass,' he says, 'When I use a word, it means just what I choose it to mean -- neither more nor less'). But the people currently preening about their compassion should have some for the English language.

Clinton's idea for helping Americans save for retirement is this: .... . She proposes to pay for this by taxing people who will be stoical about this -- dead people -- by freezing the estate tax exemption at its 2009 level. "

I posted the following comment to his column:

"Come on George. You know better! The Estate Tax is not a tax on dead people. It is a tax on their estate. A very different entity. It was instituted 100 years ago to prevent the concentration of wealth in a few people's hands. A legitimate use of the tax code. You should include yourself in the list of people using the 'Humpty Dumpty Rule.' Shame on you."

It has always been one purpose of the tax code to redistribute wealth. One major complaint about the Estate Tax was that, in order to pay it, the heirs often had to give up the "family farm". This problem can be handled by increasing exemptions, or whatever. In today's day and age, a bigger problem seems to be that no one wants to inherit the "family farm". George W. Bush doesn't mind using the tax code to redistribute wealth, except in the wrong direction.

Monday, September 3, 2007

Krugman Plays the Race Card

In an otherwise excellent column($) in today's New York Times. "Snow Job in the Desert", Paul Krugman says the following:

In February 2003, Secretary of State Colin Powell, addressing the United Nations Security Council, claimed to have proof that Saddam Hussein had weapons of mass destruction. He did not, in fact, present any actual evidence, just pictures of buildings with big arrows pointing at them saying things like “Chemical Munitions Bunker.” But many people in the political and media establishments swooned: they admired Mr. Powell, and because he said it, they believed it.
Mr. Powell’s masters got the war they wanted, and it soon became apparent that none of his assertions had been true.
********
I believe that the use of the term "masters" in this context is racist (and, believe me, I don't throw the term "racist" around lightly). The pairing, after all, is master-slave. To me, it is just a polite way of saying what Harry Belafonte said a number of years ago when he called Colin Powell a "house nigger". Belafonte later apologized, and Powell said something to the effect that " I told Harry I hoped we could get past using terms like that." I hope Krugman can get past it too.

By the way, there was some evidence. I believe there was a phone intercept talking about "cleaning things up before the inspectors come." It turned out they were talking about old stuff that might still have traces of whatever. Don't forget, Saddam did at one time have WMD's, some of them supplied by us, in which Donald Rumsfeld played a leading role.

All this vilification of Colin Powell makes me understand all the more why he didn't want to run for President. Barack Obama is feeling the heat now, and I think he should get out of the Presidential race, as I fear for his safety. I also feel there was some racism and sexism, not to mention intellectual snobbery, in the criticisms of Alberto Gonzales and Harriet Miers, but I will save this for a future post.

Friday, August 24, 2007

Krugman vs the Republicans

Below is a comment I emailed to Paul Krugman about his column($) in today's New York Times, "Seeking Willie Horton". I have sent several before, but he only posts the ones he responds to, and mine have never seen the light of day.

I enjoy your columns, but today I thought you were shooting from the hip a bit. Is it the Republican base, or the leaders, who you were aiming at? Certainly your comments don't apply to George W. Bush. Dreadful as he is, one has to admit he is genuinely inclusive when it comes to his administration (to a fault when it comes to Gonzales). But then I've thought for a long time that Bush isn't really a Republican, although not for that reason. As for Dukakis, he ran a dreadful campaign, was programmed at all times, and he never fought back, when he was asked what he would do if his wife was raped and murdered, or about the Willie Horton ads. He could have pointed out that most governors-including Reagan-give furloughs to prisoners. As for Reagan, I don't think he we was a racist and certainly not homophobic, at least on a personal level. True, he did pander, but I think one of the big reasons for all the "Reagan Democrats" was because of all the "political correctness" in the Democratic Party. And I'm afraid that this will be coming back full blast if Hillary is elected.
************
To elaborate on my last sentence: One big reason I won't vote for Hillary is that she has an agenda, spoken or not, to take us back to the 1970's, with the Equal Rights Amendment (ERA) and all the rest. Look what happened when Bill got elected: gays in the military, there has to be a female Attorney General, not to mention the health care fiasco and her channeling of Eleanor Roosevelt. Hillary, I knew Eleanor Roosevelt. Eleanor Roosevelt was a friend of mine. (well not really) And believe me, you're no Eleanor Roosevelt.

I lived through the Seventies, and I don't want to have to relive them. "Political correctness" still thrives in academe, which is one reason I'm glad to be out of there. The main organization for academic mathematicians, the American Mathematical Society (AMS), is in step with the colleges and universities on this issue. In the 1970's they decided not to hold their annual meeting in a state that had not ratified the ERA -there went Chicago- and in 1995 they moved the annual meeting out of Denver because Colorado had passed some anti-gay rights legislation, not withstanding the fact that Denver had passed some pro-gay rights legislation.

Lest you think I was an old fuddy-duddy back then, I should mention that in the late Sixties and early Seventies I was the parliamentarian for the "Mathematicians Action Group", which did plenty of rabble rousing at AMS annual and summer meetings.

If I were more mischievous, I would send a letter to the AMS Notices pointing out the following: There is a classical theorem in Number Theory called the "Chinese Remainder Theorem." I always thought it was titled that way because they didn't know which Chinese mathematician had proved it. It turns out that the name of the person is known, but hey (and here I jest) he's Chinese, and who could pronounce the name anyway? The height of political incorrectness! I suspect that such a letter would really get the "politically correct" crowd going.

Sunday, July 8, 2007

A bit too Rich for my thoughts

In his (understandably) emotional charge to trash everything about the Bush Administration, I believe that Frank Rich has at times taken leave of his thinking senses. He has always been a bit "over the top", so this is to be expected, I guess. Nevertheless, this bears commenting upon, since there are certainly other villains of this piece besides Bush, Cheney & Co. In his column($) in today's New York Times about the commuting of Scooter Libby's sentence, he says
"But if those die-hards [in Bush's base] haven’t deserted him by now, why would Mr. Libby’s incarceration be the final straw? They certainly weren’t whipped into a frenzy by coverage on Fox News, which tended to minimize the leak case as a non-event. " But his last sentence runs counter to his argument. If they viewed the leak as a non-event, then they would be more likely to be whipped into a frenzy by Libby's incarceration.

In last week's column, "When the Vice President Does It, That Means It’s Not Illegal" , he says that "hiding in plain sight was the little-noted content of the Bush executive order that Mr. Cheney is accused of violating. On close examination, this obscure 2003 document, thrust into the light only because the vice president so blatantly defied it, turns out to be yet another piece of self-incriminating evidence illuminating the White House's guilt in ginning up its false case for war. " But why was this executive order "hiding in plain sight"? It wasn't kept a secret, it's just that few people took note of it or realized its importance.

Later on in his column Rich says "Because of the Patrick Fitzgerald investigation, we would learn three years later about the offensive conducted by Mr. Libby on behalf of Mr. Cheney and Mr. Bush. That revelation prompted the vice president to acknowledge his enhanced powers in an unguarded moment in a February 2006 interview with Brit Hume of Fox News. Asked by Mr. Hume with some incredulity if "a vice president has the authority to declassify information," Mr. Cheney replied, "There is an executive order to that effect." He was referring to the order of March 2003."
Now, how does Rich know that this was an "unguarded moment"? My feeling all along has been that the Bush Administration was not really hiding its ginning up of the war. It's just that few people were paying attention to the signs of this, and those who did were not listened to. I'll never forget Paul Wolfowitz being quoted as saying "We've decided to go with WMD's as the best reason," or something to that effect. This was the subject of the infamous "Downing Street Memo," but it wasn't a surprise to me when that memo surfaced.

The sad truth is that Bush, Cheney & Co. have had plenty of enablers -in Congress, the media, and the mostly apathetic American public when it comes to anything other than entertainment, celebrities and sports. I applaud the efforts of Rich and others to get people better focused on the important issues as we deal with the fallout from the "Mushroom Cloud" of the Bush-Cheney Calamity.

Thursday, June 28, 2007

Rush to Limbaugh

Well, the battle in the Senate over the immigration bill is coming down to the wire, but is it a rush to justice or a rush to injustice? According to right-wing talk radio and many cable news programs, it is the latter, and they are marshaling the troops as never before. One interesting question is this. Are dittoheads (aka Limbaugh's loyal listeners) capable of independent thought, or are they just pawns in the hands of El Rushbo? Having listened to Limbaugh's show - less and less in recent years as he has gotten shriller and shriller - my answer to that question is a qualified "the latter." I will give an example. He rails against the "drive-by liberal media", but then he will quote them with approbation when they say something he agrees with. This inconsistency doesn't seem to bother the dittoheads. Well, as Ralph Waldo Emerson said, a foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds.
In my opinion, at the core of the immigration mess is the fact that illegals do menial jobs that can't be outsourced -in construction, agriculture, home maintenance, etc. - and often for low wages. So employers in these areas resort to "insourcing." For citizens affected by this, it is happening not in some far away third world country, but right in their own backyards!

What do I think about this? I think we should enforce existing immigration laws and secure our southern border, before anything else happens. And let's have price supports for agricultural products. We can afford it, and the workers deserve a living wage. Our grocer won't end up having to sing "Yes, we have no bananas, we have no bananas for sale."

Wednesday, June 27, 2007

Ann Coulter - Hatemonger

Excerpts from an article in today's New York Times:

RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) -- Elizabeth Edwards pleaded Tuesday with Ann Coulter to ''stop the personal attacks,'' a day after the conservative commentator said she wished Edwards' husband, Democratic presidential candidate John Edwards, had been killed by terrorists.
''The things she has said over the years, not just about John but about other candidates, lowers the political dialogue at precisely the time we need to raise it,'' Edwards said by phone on MSNBC's ''Hardball'' program, where Coulter was a guest. .....
Coulter responded with a laugh and charged that Edwards was calling on her to stop speaking altogether. ''I don't think I need to be told to stop writing by Elizabeth Edwards, thank you,'' Coulter said. ....
On ABC's ''Good Morning America'' on Monday, Coulter was asked about a March speech in which she used a gay slur to refer to Edwards. ''If I'm going to say anything about John Edwards in the future, I'll just wish he had been killed in a terrorist assassination plot,'' Coulter said, picking up on remarks made by HBO's Bill Maher. Maher suggested in March that ''people wouldn't be dying needlessly'' if Vice President Dick Cheney had been killed in an insurgent attack in Afghanistan.
(end of excerpts)
There are two points worth making. First, Maher is a comedian, which I suppose cuts him some slack. Second, and more importantly, he was referring to something that had actually happened (the insurgent attack) while Cheney was visiting Afghanistan. Coulter's wish, on the other hand, was for something that has not occurred, but was merely a figment of her imagination. This is inciting and hateful. She does not deserve a seat at the media table any more then Pat Buchanan does. (See my earlier post.)

My favorite story about comedians making threats concerns Groucho Marx. When Nixon was President, and Groucho was in his 80's, he evidently said that the only alternative left was assassination. The Secret Service considered whether to bring charges against him (Arrest Groucho Marx?), but finally decided to treat his remark as a joke.

Monday, June 4, 2007

Making Salaries Public?

There was a fairly silly Op-Ed column "Show Us the Money" in today's New York Times, arguing that it is in the public interest that salaries be made public, and giving the Supreme Court as an example. Here is a letter to the editor I sent in response.

The author seems unable to distinguish between private corporations and publicly funded entities such as the Supreme Court, where salaries are not based on merit. Now it is true that in publicly traded companies, the salaries of the top officials are public knowledge, but do we want all salaries to be public? A lot of organizations use a "grade" or "rank" system, and usually one's grade or rank is known by fellow employees. School teachers are sometimes paid by a matrix method: If you have this or that degree, and if you have worked this or that many years, then your salary is X. This is totally transparent, but based more on longevity than on merit. If it is unfair to pay two people different salaries for the same job, do we now want to add humiliation into the mix by making this fact public? There must be better and more confidential remedies for this problem.